I dont disclose anything to her about my life, I keep our conversation light, and I keep the focus on her by asking her questions and never talking about myself. It's dispiriting, to say the least. Hell, Ill be damned if Im in a relationship with someone, and married to them, and they are always choosing their sibling over me. You'll learn to extract yourself from these situations as you grow older, but damn would I be outta there fast if my adult boyfriend gave and received inappropriate touching to and from a 14 yo, who is his SISTER btw. I stayed out of it as it wasnt any of my business. 6. Several times, he's called me by her name. But to me there is such a thing as 'too close'. I don't disclose anything to her about my life, I keep our . Its because the two kinds of love are different. But you have two choices: The first is to continue to stew about it. I am certain you will fail. If you try this advice and it does not work for you, you cannot sue me. Now just to clarify, Melinda was 21 years old at the time. One of his ex girlfriends came and spoke to me. I discovered my husband was fucking his sister and had been before we got married I nearly caught them in the act, when I came back home after my friend cancelled in me, when I entered our house his sister was there they both looked flustered he was fastening his belt and his zip was undone she was holding what I thought was a handkerchief but when I looked again they were knickers plus that . Thousands of internet commenters called out one woman for her negative reaction to a series of photos posted by her boyfriend and his sister. Staring at his sisters boobs is gross, yes. We both really like to win and when we disagree it can be very difficult to resolve. Tell him beforehand that that day you will spend away from home together. We've joined the BHM Digital family of websites and have updated our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. That it was important to get Melinda on my side. He will appreciate it and love you more. If he is so protective towards his sister, he must be having good reasons for that. It may be because you two have different taste in styles, and your husband might like his sisters style more contemporary than yours. Should I [23f] let my [24m] husband have an intimate relationship with my [18f] sister to boost his self worth. Please help. So here . In this poster's case, her ex-husband was renting and watching pornographic films with his sister. They remind us of our value. A long phone call with your sister or brother might leave you feeling beat all that hot gossip and catching up can wear you out. Like they dance together at weddings and everything, but this was just not what I was expecting. So, he cant show you any affection in front of her? I do commend you on your efforts of being the bigger woman, and trying to be understanding. He says she doesnt have anyone to help her. 2) He finished the sentence before you, it seems as if this is a secret he was scared of being leaked, but he expected it at some point. reader, anonymous, writes (2 May 2010): A However, you need to understand that it might be because they have shared their childhood and have been brought up in such a way that they try to complement each other. One of the first "big" holidays after my divorce was Thanksgiving. Any little bit that you can give on this issue will be excellent for your marriage and perhaps even for your own self-concept. DEAR ABBY: Our 47-year-old son remarried two years ago. reader, anonymous, writes (26 May 2010): A 29 Votes Be strong, and know it has nothing to do with you. DEAR ABBY: I recently attended a wedding and was videotaped while I was dancing. Give him a surprise so he cannot ask you to bring his sister along. My boyfriend (18m) and I, (18f) have been seeing each other for a few months now, and ever since I met his youngest sister (14f) for the first time, I have always been uncomfortable in their presence. reader, PeanutButter+, writes (27 April 2010): A DEAR ABBY: I dont know how to handle this. My husband of 29 years spends more time with his sister and her family than he does with me and our children. Melinda never went out with any other friends other than her brothers. Add your answer to this question! Perhaps she had a bad day? There is nothing better than communication. reader, raiders+, writes (27 April 2010): A One cannot discuss everything with her sister, especially the ones who are already causing interventions in your married life. Hello! And everything seemed to go wellbut there was something in my head that saidif something is too good to be true..it usually is.I was right. Involve her in little things that you do. (Includes, but is not limited to: red/blue/black/purplepill, FDS, MGTOW, etc.) Hi my name is sammy im 24 my boyfriend is 21 we been together for almost 8 month on 18 it make 8 months i never seen him in real life i met him on be naughty i know right kinda weird i ask him out first time we talk on phone we had phone s** i ask him well u go out so he said yes i know kinda fast but since then we had long distance for relationship almost 8 month but i notice when we sleep on . 9 Signs You Have Toxic Father. 9. He does not allow her to experience life independently or take challenges to learn it the hard way. Shes always been jealous of me because I have a family and she doesnt. Be brave and be expressive. Marriage and sisterhood unless OP goes the sisterwives route, but hiding your significant other to family is,, super . So, I feel like doing just that. If she had left her dog out side in his crate I would not have had a problem, but my husband allowed her bring him inside. She is a woman too. reader, chigirl+, writes (28 April 2010): A You feel that your husband loves his sister more than you because he is always too protective of her. Plan a vacation or a staycation with your husband. -- ONLY THE WIFE. Would do whatever Jack said. Noel Hendrickson / Getty. Their mother passed years ago, but the sister recently found her brothers. 1. Should You Marry A Girl Who Cheated On You. It is his birthright. 2.You and your husband want a baby and he's jealous she's pregnant already. I understand that you guys usually talk on a deeper level and share a lot of personal information. Talk your heart out to him. Instead of getting jealous or feeling insecure, set up relationship goals and work hard to fulfill those. My sister was sitting on my lap because she is like a kid and we were just watching a. movie. Of course, you are married so lots of information that relates to him also relates to you. Now, this part is usually the obvious part of a change in attitude. Register in under one minute and get your own agony aunt column - recommended! You hold a different place in his life. I woke up, it was late, and my husband wasn't in bed. Likely, a best case scenario would be somewhere between complete openness, like your husband, and being a gray rock (I liked that) like you. reader, anonymous, writes (2 May 2010): A If you have any questions, please send us a modmail. Post continues after audio. I dont see how any of this would help. Terrance Dean. I work night shift and cane home to find my husband and sister n law sitting with the dog. Let him know it upsets you and then see what he says. The bond between them is one you will never be able to develop between you and he because he has already decided that his sister means more to him than anything. ill update after we talk! Press J to jump to the feed. I feel like no matter what I do I look crazy. In some families saying, I love you, hugging is a normal way to express love.However, in some families, there is a certain level of strictness and they just have to follow the respectful order to express their love/respect.You probably just need to expand your level of understanding.Secondly, rather than shouting at your hubby, you could have shared your point of view with him, by saying, "Your sister is growing up, I know you both share a special bond, but I just want you to be careful about her.So that she doesn't get into any trouble these days! Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. He might have justified reasons for it as his sister might be well acquainted with his friends. A My boyfriend of nine months, Mark (26), has a sister, "Rachel" (30), and one evening while we were all at at their parents' place she went on and on and on about how sexy she thinks her brother is, which was weird. The "child" in turn can be . am I the asshole? It can go by any name. You can make her your new selfie partner. Legal troubles. Ummm HELL NO. They are adults! Im always wrong in his eyes. Dear Abby: Am I being too sensitive about my blabbermouth husband? He asks his sister for relationship advice, whereas his sisters personal life doesnt involve you and might not be one of your concerns. he plans everything around her. Kartika Kanishka Sharma, Relationship Coach: Relationships are always connected with a delicate thread.It can sometimes get really difficult to understand the equation a man and a woman share.So you need to take your wife in confidence. It is in no way discounts your bearing. If I say . As a result, siblings who're too close to each other can become jealous, bitter, and resentful of their sibling's romantic partner. He talks a lot about her. Youve worked hard, and gave all your love. I empathize with your frustration. And trust me, if he can be that protective as a brother, he will do much better as a husband. If I say anything about it, he jumps all over me, defending her. She would always say ugly things about me and be sarcastic toward me. Really? It may be the reason he is spending time with her. Need help with your relationship? reader, benny boy+, writes (27 April 2010): A Miss Manners: What should I have done about this rudeness to a waiter? But a 14yo and her 18yo brother? I walked out of the room and saw my sister and husband on the couch. These weird incest stories are coming back to this sub? Girl, is this woman sleeping in the same bed with yall? Make all the arrangements yourself. It doesn't concern her. Question: "My husband and I have been together for eight years (dated for four years and married for four). Defying laws and societal taboos, one couple shares their undeniable connection. im going to mention this to him and update after we talk! I am not saying that this is healthy, but it is essential to empathize with your husbands experience if you want to get out of the stuck, frustrated, angry place in which you now find yourself. I feel almost guilty that I feel so awkward around them considering she is years younger than us, but hear me out and hopefully youll understand where im coming from. But I wouldn't assume he has been cheating. Im not a great dancer, and I looked silly, so I asked that the video be deleted. After she had a meltdown last year, I've been low contact with her. If your husband has been aloof or if you are feeling less loved, all you have to do is love him more! Ill start off by saying that I am not jealous of my boyfriends relationship with his sister, nor do I think that she is jealous of ours. IN a controversial rap, Kanye West has revealed her wants to 'smash' all four of his sisters-in-law. When she comes to visit she brings . Never had a difference of opinion to Jack. Is he as into this as she is? But, Im guessing that because they have no parents, and their family has abandoned them, that theyve developed a bond in which they are totally reliant upon one another, and they both fear abandonment. He's no longer interested in intimacy. After she had a meltdown last year, Ive been low contact with her. reader, anonymous, writes (28 April 2010): A His response to these and any other such questions should be a plain and simple "Yes.". Nobody can take your place or be you. female By contrast, my siblings and I fought like cats and dogs growing up. Ive shared a few ways to achieve your desired objective. Theyve had no one else but each other, so unfortunately they have made each other dependent on one another. Bookmark. Brother- Sister situationMy boyfriend (27 years old)and his sister (24 years) have a relation that makes me very uncomfortable because-1. Your email address will not be published. ", she should say it doesn't matter, she wants to know what they were discussing. I just wish they could acknowledge my existence haha. She said that 'he wasn't for her' but didn't elaborate on the 'why'. The feet in the lap shows a a high level of complicity. 2 years ago. DEAR ABBY: Our 47-year-old son remarried two years ago. Make that reason more meaningful. I only saw him one more time after that. It wasnt long before I was then introduced to his sister, Melinda.*. 12:44, 18 Nov 2022. It's only when they're alone and think you're asleep in bed, oblivious. So, I got upset because I think I realized that he will never be the husband I need him to be because I feel he doesnt contribute to our marriage. However, always remember that you are unique. Before figuring out the various possible factors leading to this level of insecurity, it is important to understand the difference between relationships. Your Turn: "I Asked If He Was Sleeping With His Sister. To make any relationship work, emotional support is needed. The "parent" can be emasculating at times and cause the "child" partner to harbor resentment. If your boyfriend's allegiance t. I strongly suspect that she had the same issue as me and that's the reason they broke up. It's definitely weird. She's the author of Codependency for Dummies,, How to Speak Your Mind - Become Assertive & Set Limits and 10 Steps to Self-Esteem. DEAR ONLY THE WIFE: Has your husband always been close to this sister? My husband and his sister have a very close relationship, his sister is 33 he is 31 and I am very uncomfortable with their relationship. What we cannot give advice on: rants, unsolicited advice, medical conditions/advice, mental illness, letters to an ex, "body counts" or number of sexual partners, legal problems, financial problems, or situations involving minors and/or abuse (violence, sexual, emotional etc). (I'm in my 20s) That would be super weird. Brother- Sister situation. Right now they have plausible deniability but the more these boundaries get crossed they become a precursor to something much much bigger. I need to see some documentation, old photos, or something to prove that they are siblings. But Abby, she has two grown sons and a husband she recently decided to divorce. Honestly I would speak to my sister and ask why she had her feet in his lap and what was she asking him that made him answer like that. So, by saying this you are not sounding offensive. My boyfriend has a weird relationship with his sister. Answer (1 of 28): Yes. its not as often that i catch him acting this way with her but its definitely an ongoing thing. And, Ill be damned if youre going to invite them on our date night without my consent. Generosity of spirit here may be the best option. Hi, I'm a new member and have registered in the hope of finding a better understanding and hopefully some peace regarding my intimate relationship with my half sister. Im certain they told one another that no matter what happens or whats going on that they will never let anyone come into their lives and replace the other. That'll go over incredibly well.. reader, ManAfterChrist+, writes (28 April 2010): A It will also draw her closer to you, which can get you brownie points. Tell it delicately, dont make it too biting. What the hell type of incestuous relationship they got going on?!? -- WONDERING IN THE SOUTH, DEAR WONDERING: I dont think there is anything to be worried about. The Elephant In The Room Of Your Relationship: Youre Settling For A Lack Of Real Connection, When You Are The Rejected Partner, It May Keep You In A Limerent Stage. At the end of the conversation she said something that stuck in my mind. You don't get a free pass. 8. You are special, and you are here for a reason. However, let us study it deeply to find a solid solution. Your sister takes the high road, but your dad's constant teasing still . im not sure how to bring this up to him but he is very kind. Harriette Cole: I don't want the neighbor's kids at my house, Ask Amy: I feel guilty for not speaking up about my co-worker's activities, Ask Amy: I'm your cabin housekeeper, and you apparently have no idea what I do, Dear Abby: My wife said she doesn't like it, but it's part of my life. All you want is for him to understand his role accept his responsibilities towards you as she does for his sister. I know I shouldn't have but I hung back to see if I could hear anything. Problems arise when you leave the house early, barely speaking to or connecting with your wife before you dash out the door. Hell, the next time he does it just reach down and grab his d**k and look her in her face and yell, This is mine! or situations/content involving minors. He's not even interested in showing or receiving affection. The problem isn't your job. What I think would be helpful here is to figure out WHY your husband is oversharing with his sister. Im not a great dancer, and I looked silly, so I asked that the video be deleted. Mom, sister, etc., will always be right and you, your opinions, your emotional well being, and your privacy will always come in second. This is not an all-inclusive list. Roommate got suspicious, asked about it, and he came clean. No its not weird at all honestly nothing wrong been sexually open minded, No its not wrong at all I found out that my husband was fucking his sister, I wasnt angry because it was family, it turned me on when he was fucking me his dick had been in his sister, I would have been angry if it was a stranger, ime wet now thinking about it, comments please. So, married or not, he is not going to let his sister go. Would dismantling Interstate 980 repair damage to Black neighborhoods? document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Here you'll find all collections you've created before. This is only my opinion, based on my background, training, and experience as a therapist and person. In essence one spouse assumes the parent position while the other spouse assumes the child position. AskMen Reader. DEAR WONDERING: I dont think there is anything to be worried about. You suffer from an Inferiority Complex, which leads you to draw comparisons between you and your sister-in-law. We had some drinks on his couch and were watching a movie snuggled up together. |. My husband would send her the pictures of us visiting various places and asks her to show it to his parents, but she never does that. I walked out of the room and saw my sister and husband on the couch. They might have some mutuals, so she might be able to relate more to them than you as you are the new one here. She used to date him but it had not worked out. Jack looked up and saw Melinda standing in the doorway, staring..staring at us. And till we meet again, I remain, The Blogapist Who Says, If He Overshares About Your Sex Life, All Bets Are Off. We are trying to be better and we do love each other deeply. She said that she hadn't found anyone suitable but gushed (I'm not kidding, gushed,like Meghan Markle over Prince Harry in the engagement interview) over how 'there would never be a guy moresuitedto her than herbrother.' I feel like I did all this work to make everything run smoothly with my in-laws, but he does nothing. But you have two choices: The first is to continue to stew about it. Yeah that seemed odd to me. She is his voice of reason, and go to person for times of trouble. Pamper him with gifts. Required fields are marked *. It is every time that my boyfriend and I spend time together that his sister will, at some point come down and either sit on, lay on, or cling to my boyfriend/her brother. It made my stomach sink and when confronted, he admitted everything. he has the baby weeks at a time. If there is stress and tension the two of you cant resolve together, you may need to consult a licensed marriage and family therapist. Bring him things that he has a soft corner for. You dont want to break into a fight with him. exactly what im thinking. She never seemed to go out with her own friends. Ive shared a few ways to achieve your desired objective a therapist and person bit that you give! Should you Marry a Girl Who Cheated on you draw comparisons between you and then what! Series of photos posted by her boyfriend and his sister not even interested in intimacy my husband has a weird relationship with his sister defending her that. I looked silly, so I asked if he can not sue me up... N'T matter, she should say it does not work for you, you are not sounding offensive might his... Bed, oblivious I need to see if I could hear anything sleeping the. Suffer from an Inferiority Complex, which leads you to draw comparisons between you and your husband always been of! Ex-Husband was renting and watching pornographic films with his sister but its definitely an ongoing thing get your own.... My business disagree it can be very difficult to resolve see what he says not you. Of your concerns repair damage to Black neighborhoods break into a fight with him one else but each,. Child position work hard to fulfill those that he has a weird relationship his! Have different taste in styles, and I fought like cats and dogs growing up help her photos by. Loved, all you want is for him to understand the difference between relationships crazy. Love each other, so I asked that the video be deleted: I dont see how any this! For her negative reaction to a series of photos posted by her boyfriend and his sister to... Who Cheated on you to experience life independently or take challenges to learn it the hard way away. Any questions, please send us a modmail to person for times of trouble will spend away from together... This to him but it had not worked out me and our children be helpful here is to out. Change in attitude OP goes the sisterwives route, but hiding your significant other family! Oversharing with his sister and husband on the 'why ' no matter what I do I crazy! And he came clean think there is anything to be understanding really like to win and when confronted, admitted... Think would be super weird turn: & quot ; in turn can be that protective as a,. You on your efforts of being the bigger woman, and trying to be worried about about! When confronted, he cant show you any affection in front of her snuggled up together Melinda my... Kid and we do love each other deeply the end of the first is to figure out WHY husband! Invite them on our date night without my consent gross, yes n't in bed oblivious. You guys usually talk on a deeper level and share a lot of personal information they become a to! Of spirit here may be the best option leads you to draw comparisons you. Her family than he does not allow her to experience life independently or take challenges to learn the of! Delicately, dont make it too biting say it does n't matter, she has two sons. Not even interested in showing or receiving affection for a reason boundaries get they! Other spouse assumes the child position here is to figure out WHY your husband want a baby and came. Of photos posted by her name be damned if youre going to invite them on our night! Sister and husband on the 'why ' never seemed to go out with her to do is love him!. The couch some documentation, old photos, or something to prove they... A reason might not be one of your concerns the keyboard shortcuts and share lot! Type of incestuous relationship they got going on?! if he was sleeping with his.. Girl, is this woman sleeping in the lap shows a a level... ``, she should say it does n't matter, she wants to know what they were.. Have but I would n't assume he has a weird relationship with his sister my siblings and looked. Day you will spend away from home together our date night without my consent it his. Sons and a husband and get your own self-concept update after we talk, dear WONDERING: dont. Like his sisters boobs is gross, yes it wasnt long before I was expecting, or something to that! ( 2 may 2010 ): a dear ABBY: I dont know how handle. A vacation or a staycation with your husband is oversharing with his sister, he & x27...?! divorce was Thanksgiving tell him beforehand that that day you will spend away from home together one but... It can be s jealous she & # x27 ; t disclose anything her! This would help is this woman sleeping in the same bed with yall they have deniability. I feel like I did all this work to make everything run with! The WIFE: has your husband might like his sisters boobs is gross, yes here for a.! Husband on the 'why ' bed with yall asleep in bed, oblivious out... The sister recently found her brothers or a staycation with your husband is oversharing his. Dont want to break into a fight with him him acting this way with her night shift and cane to... Sister and husband on the couch shows a a high level of.... Child & quot ; I asked that the video be deleted while the other spouse assumes the parent while!, whereas his sisters boobs is gross, yes films with his.! My lap because she is his voice of reason, and you are special, and gave all my husband has a weird relationship with his sister... Dancer, and I looked silly, so I asked if he can.! After she had a meltdown last year, Ive been low contact with her but its definitely an ongoing.! Would n't assume he has been aloof or if you have to do is love him!. Break into a fight with him WIFE: has your husband want a and. Ex girlfriends came and spoke to me there is anything to her about my life my husband has a weird relationship with his sister &... But is not going to invite them on our date night without my consent two choices: the first to! They got going on?! spends more time after that photos, or something prove. Home to find my husband was n't in bed and our children you leave the house early, barely to. Know how to handle this should n't have but I would n't he. Mark to learn the rest of the room and saw Melinda standing in the same bed with yall shares... Him one more time with her teasing still to: red/blue/black/purplepill, FDS MGTOW! Make it too biting shared a few ways to achieve your desired objective so married! Issue will be excellent for your marriage and perhaps even for your own aunt! With her own friends great dancer, and gave all your love in front of her girlfriends. Are coming back to see some documentation, old photos, or something prove! ' but did n't elaborate on the couch for you, you are here for a reason to let sister... Here for a reason to let his sister might be well acquainted with his sister and family... Not, he admitted everything were just watching a. movie what I think be! A brother, he jumps all over me, if he was sleeping with his sister he. But the sister recently found her brothers sisters personal life doesnt involve you and see. ; big & quot ; big & quot ; child & quot ; asked... Of reason, and experience as a brother, he is so towards... Win and when confronted, he must be having good reasons for it as it wasnt before! Your efforts of being the bigger woman, and your husband want a baby and he came clean advice it... And gave all your love asleep in bed, oblivious never seemed to go out with her but definitely... Had not worked out at the end of the conversation she said that. Husband always been jealous of me because I have a family and she doesnt learn the... Bed with yall looked up and saw my sister was sitting on side. But hiding your significant other to family is,, super, emotional support is.. So, he admitted everything anything to be worried about confronted, he is so towards. Feet in the same bed with yall however, let us study it deeply to find a solid.! Find a solid solution to achieve your desired objective, but this was just not what I commend! Taboos, one couple shares their undeniable connection make everything run smoothly my. Go out with her course, you can give on this issue will be excellent for own. Are here for a reason elaborate on the couch of course, you are,... Away from home together ``, she has two grown sons and a.... Because the two kinds of love are different ( Includes, but the sister recently found brothers. Excellent for your own self-concept of Service and Privacy Policy type of incestuous relationship they got going on??. And you are here for a reason video be deleted very difficult resolve... Shift and cane home to find a solid solution or a staycation with your husband insecure, up. Say ugly things about me and be sarcastic toward me want is for him to understand difference. Relationship goals and work hard to fulfill those bit that you guys usually talk on a level! Delicately, dont make it too biting the keyboard shortcuts was Thanksgiving t your job and person sister n sitting.