This is a list of questionable, scholarly open-access publishers. CONSORTIUM Intellectual Consortium of Drug Discovery and Technology Development, Inc. East West Association For Advanced Studies and Higher Education, The Economics and Social Development Organization, E-International Journals of Academic & Scientific Research, E-International Scientific Research Journal Consortium, Einstein International Journal Organization, Electronic Center for International Scientific Information, Euro Asia Research and Development Association, European Center for Science Education and Research, Foundation for Promotion of Basic & Applied Science, Fundamental Research and Development International, Global Institute for Research and Education, International Academy of Science and Higher Education, Global Society of Scientific Research and Researchers, Global Technocrats & Intellectuals Association, Greenfield Advanced Research Publishing House, Human Resource Management Academic Research Society, i-Explore International Research Journals Consortium, Indian Academicians and Researchers Association, Indian Society for Education and Environment, Indus Foundation for Education, Research & Social Welfare, Information Engineering Research Institute, The Institute for Business and Finance Research, Institute for Research and Development India, Institute of Advanced Scientific Research, Institute of Doctors Engineers and Scientists, Institute of Electronic & Information Technology, Institute of Integrative Omics and Applied Biotechnology, Institute of Language and Communication Studies, Institute of Research Engineers and Doctors, Institute of Research Engineers and Scientists, Institute of Research In Engineering and Technology, Institute of Strategic and International Studies, Intercontinental Management Research Review, International Academy for Advancement of Business Research, International Academy for Science & Technology Education and Research, International Academy of Arts, Science & Technology, International Academy of Business & Economics, International Academy of Computer & IT Engineering, International Academy of Ecology and Environmental Sciences, International Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology, International Academy of Science, Technology, Engineering and Management, The International Academy, Research and Industry Association, International Agency for Development of Culture, Education and Science, International Association for Engineering & Technology, International Association for Engineering and Management Education, International Association for Information, Culture, Human and Industry Technology, International Association of Computer Science and Information Technology, International Association of Advances in Engineering and Technology, International Association of Engineering & Technology Researchers, International Association of Journals & Conferences, International Association of Scientific Innovation and Research, International Association of Technology Education & Industry, International Center for Business Research, International Centre for Integrated Development Research, International Centre of Culture Inventory, International Computer Science and Engineering Society, International Conference on Computer Science and Engineering, International Digital Organization for Scientific Information, International Economics Development and Research Center, International Education Research Foundation, International Educative Research Foundation And Publisher, International Forum of Researchers Students and Academician, International Foundation for Modern Education and Scientific Research, International Foundation for Research and Development, International House for Academic Scientific Research, International Indexed Refereed Research Journal, International Institute for Private, Commercial and Competition Law, International Institute for Science, Technology and Education, International Institute of Engineers & Researchers, International Institute of Informatics and Systemics, International Institute of Science & Industry Research, International Journal of College & University, International Journal of Research & Development Organisation, The International Journal Research Publications, International Journal of Academic Research, International Journals of Engineering & Sciences, International Journals of Multi Dimensional Research, International Journals of Multidisciplinary Research Academy, International Journals of N&N Global Technology, International Journals of Research Papers, International Journals of Sciences and High Technologies, International Journals of Scientific Knowledge, International Journals of Scientific Research Publications, International Journals of Scientific Research, International Network for Applied Sciences and Technology, International Network for Natural Sciences, International Network for Scientific & Industrial Information, International Online Knowledge Services Provider, International Organization Center of Academic Research, International Organization of Scientific Invention, International Organization of Scientific Research, International Organization of Scientific Research and Development, International Publisher for Advanced Scientific Journals, International Recognition Multidisciplinary Research Journals, Monthly Publish, International Recognition Research Journals, International Research Association of Computer Science, & Technology, International Research Organization of Computer Science, International Research Society For Promotion of Science, International Scholarly Open Access Research, International Science & Research Journals, International Science and Medical Journals, International Science Community Association, International Scientific Academic Corporation, International Scientific Academy of Engineering & Technology, International Scientific Engineering and Research Publications, International Scientific Invention Journals, International Scientific Research Organization for Science, Engineering and Technology, International Scientific Research Organization Journals, International Society for Engineering Research and Development, International Society for Engineers and Researchers, International Society for green.sustainable engineering and management, International Society for Zoological Research, International Society of Thesis Publication, International Society of Universal Research in Sciences, Islamic World Network for Environmental Science and Technology, Journal of Harmonized Research Publications, Journal of The International Association of Advanced Technology and Science, Knowledge Publishing Printing & Distribution House, Mediterranean Center of Social and Educational Research, Muhammadon Centre for Research and Development, North Asian International Research Journal Consortium, Philippine Association of Institutions for Research, International Journal of Academic Research (Publisher), Research and Scientific Innovation Society, Research Centre for Management and Social Studies, Research Institute for Progression of Knowledge, Research Institute for Science, Technology, and Society, Research, Science, and Technology Publishers, Scholars Academic and Scientific Publishers, Science & Engineering Research Support soCiety, Science & Knowledge Publishing Corporation Limited, Science and Education Centre of North America, Science and Engineering Publishing Company, Science Park Research Organization and Counseling, Sciences & Engineering Research Publication, Scientific Institute For Advanced Training and Studies, ScottishGroup Education and Testing Services, Shri Param Hans Education & Research Foundation Trust, Smith & Franklin Academic Publishing Corporation, Society for Science and Education United Kingdom, Society of Digital Information and Wireless Communications, Society of Engineering Science and Technology. 69, no. DOAJ is a unique and extensive index of diverse open access journals from around the world, driven by a growing community, committed to ensuring quality content is freely available online for everyone. Australian International Academic Centre Pty. WebHeliyon is an allscience open access journal that is part of the Cell Press family. 13 evidence-based characteristics by which predatory journals may potentially be distinguished from Please note that funds for other reductions are limited, however, as the journal would not be sustainable without income from author charges to cover its cost. Ltd. Australian International Research Consortium, Australian Society for Commerce Industry & Engineering, Austrian E-Journals of Universal Scientific Organization, Bioscience Research & Educational Institute, Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering & Sciences Publication, Cairo Center for Development Benchmarking. For example. WebMany insects eat their cast cuticle (exuviae) after moulting. Mechanistic study of on-site sludge reduction in a baffled bioreactor consisting of three series of alternating aerobic and anaerobic compartments. Removing your preprint from SSRN will not impact the review process at Heliyon. (. We welcome researchersin all corners of the world, from all disciplines, and at all career stagesand help them advance their research with a streamlined publication process led by subject-area experts who understand the unique needs of your community. To update your cookie settings, please visit the. You can find stats such as acceptance rate, journal impact factor, months to publication, submission processes and contact information. These evaluations cast doubt on their commitment to integrity, taken in this context to be the active adherence to the ethical principles and professional standards essential for the responsible practice of research (Korenman, n.d., as cited in, While certain authors have held that there is no clear definition of predatory journals (. WebDisconnection of the right superior parietal lobule from the precuneus is associated with memory impairment in oldest-old Alzheimer's disease patients How to spot a journal that exhibits non-standard behavior. The content on this site is intended for healthcare professionals and researchers across all fields of science. The example I am going to talk about is a journal for which I wrote one review: Heliyon. Legitimate journals simply do not commit lapses. They assess papers on their merit, validity, and strength of technical and ethical soundness. 1 Identifier ces revues et comprendre leur fonctionnement. Elsevier published 6 fake journals. These dedicated sections allow us to tailor each author's experience to the needs and standards they have come to expect within their respective fields. In the last edition of Editors Update, we highlighted the impending launch of Heliyon Elseviers new open access journal publishing sound research across all Red flags that may indicate a "predatory journal. 2022, Received in revised form: All the communication, visibility, impact, publishing, and other strategies described above are ploys to increase profits at the expense of scholarship (according to the definition published in, The first factor to consider is a misperception of the risks that attach to publishing in these journals (, This widespread unawareness among researchers has been studied by authors like. Scientific publishing giant Elsevier put out a total of six publications between 2000 and 2005 that were sponsored by unnamed DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e08999. Secondly, these corrupt practices should be included as a subject of study in instructor and researcher training programs. In the case of Heliyon First Look on SSRN, the authors submitted manuscript will be uploaded to SSRN once it is sent for review. Please enter a term before submitting your search. Any paper reporting scientifically accurate and valuable research, which adheres to accepted Check the information listed on the website (name, location, time in existence most are recent, editorial board, digital storage policy, editorial standards, publication procedure, plagiarism prevention systems, ISSN, DOI, rejection rate, and so forth). Identification of autophagy related genes in predicting the prognosis and aiding 5- fluorouracil therapy of colorectal cancer, Evaluation of RevX solution extract as a potential inhibitor of the main protease of SARS-CoV-2In vitro study and molecular docking, How to spot a journal that exhibit non-standard behavior. Authors pay article processing charges, access is free to readers. Predatory journals: what are they and how to identify them?. All this has transformed the scholarly and scientific publishing scene and has opened the door to the appearance of journals whose editorial procedures differ from those of legitimate journals. These publishers are called predatory, because their manuscript publishing process deviates from the norm (very short publication times, non-existent or low-quality Predatory journals: no definition, no defense. Spring City Culture International Group Pte Ltd. Spring International S&T Publishing Media Co. Sri Krishna International Research & Educational Consortium, Transaction Series on Engineering Sciences and Technologies, Universal Association of Computer and Electronics Engineers, Universal Association of Mechanical and Aeronautical Engineers, Universal Publishing & Research Organization, Virtual Foundation for Advancement of Science and Technology, World Academic Journal of Business & Applied Science, World Academy of Research and Publication, World Academy of Research in Science and Engineering, World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology, World Scientific and Engineering Academy and Society, Zenith International Research and Academic Foundation, Advanced Research Society for Science and Sociology, Birlesik Dunya Yenilik Arastirma ve Yayincilik Merkezi, Center for Promoting Education and Research, Centre for Research on Islamic Banking & Finance and Business, Institute for Environment, Engineering, Economics, Institute for Promoting Research & Policy Development, International Association for Research and Science, International Association of Science and Technology for Development, International Business Academics Consortium, International Center for Promoting Knowledge, International Institute of Education, Research and Development, International Institute of Social and Economic Sciences, International Journal of Modern Research and Development, International Peer Reviewed Journals and Books, International Technology and Science Publications Ltd, Journal of Scientific and Engineering Research, Natural Science Simulations and Engineering Laboratory Limited, United Prime Publications, Universal Access Medical Publishers, Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute (MDPI), The Scholarly Kitchen: Guest Post MDPIs Remarkable Growth, UNDARK: Opinion: I Published a Fake Paper in a Peer-Reviewed Journal, Nature Index: Retractions: the good, the bad, and the ugly, Canadian Academy of Oriental and Occidental Culture, Canadian Research & Development Center of Sciences and Cultures, Global International Scientific Analytical Project (GISAP), see. Revues prdatrices : une vraie menace pour la recherche mdicale. You will then receive an email that contains a secure link for resetting your password, If the address matches a valid account an email will be sent to __email__ with instructions for resetting your password. Read more about Elsevier on the topic of diversity. The APC is due upon the acceptance of a paper for publication. Lastly, to avoid using reductionist terminology when referring to this type of journal e.g., phony publishers (. "This is a list of questionable, scholarly open-access publishers. There are reputable journal and book publishers that are completely open or have open access options. Furthermore, their operations tend to lack transparency, an aspect included in certain authors' definitions. WebHeliyon is a Web of Science indexed journal tha publishes research in the area: MULTIDISCIPLINARY SCIENCES - SCIE(Q2). Any paper reporting scientifically accurate and valuable research, which adheres ; dead links and no information about the publisher's physical address; a look and interface that mimics the design of a well-known publisher, the email address is a popular one (Gmail or Yahoo) or not listed at all ( web form only), no information about editorial or advisory boards, a large number of published titles (especially for new presses). January 16, As an author you can expect a simple, straightforward, transparent and timely publication process. 24% woman 74% man 0% non-binary or gender diverse 2% prefer not to disclose. Heliyon is a completely open access megajournal from Elsevier that publishes robust research across all disciplines. Heliyon is actively building individual research subject sections that are managed by respected researchers and experts in the field. This work was supported by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (MCI), the National Research Agency (AEI) and the European Regional Development Fund (ERDF) (Grant number: RTI2018-098314-B-I00). Open-access mega journals: the future of scholarly communication or academic dumping ground? Some universities or organizations maintain internal black lists of predatory journals (, Do not publish in these journals, do not serve on their editorial or scientific boards, and be averse to citing the articles they publish (, Do not participate in any fraudulent action promoted by questionable publishers such as fake conferences, an emerging phenomenon that continues to attract adherents (. Nelson, Nerissaand JenniferHuffman. WebThe journal welcomes submissions from the research community where attention will be on the novelty and the practical importance of the reported work. Check the journal's copyright assignment policy and whether authors have to bear the cost of publication. Heliyon has a small budget for reducing open access charges for authors in developing countries and others in genuine financial hardship. Patterns and determinants of change in cortisol levels and thyroid function as a function of cardiac risk in children undergoing cardiac surgery Mohammed WebHeliyon Submit your Paper View Articles Open Access Articles Mental health burden for NHS healthcare staff during the COVID-19 pandemic: First results of a longitudinal survey The object of this article is to spell out the editorial practices of these journals to make them easier to spot and thus to alert researchers who are unfamiliar with them. A scoping review. Heliyon is indexed in PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science Science Citation Index Expanded (SCIE). Predatory journals are journals that charge publication fees to authors without providing legitimate peer review services prior to publication. More checklists, indicators and rubrics to use in your evaluation: [From John Jay College of Criminal Justice LibGuide], mass mailings of unsolicited invitations to contribute to a journal (these spam-like invitations shouldn't be confused with the emails received from the scholarly organizations you are a member of or with emails from the journal or publisher where your past work has appeared), a strikingly quick turnaround from submission to publication, peer review process not explained and conducted in no time, the title resembles the title of a well-known publication, the title suggests an overly broad or extremely vague scope (e.g., Galaxy: International Multidisciplinary Research Journal, British Journal of Science), although the title specifies location ("European Journal") the journal is located in another part of the world, the publisher's website include typos and grammatical errors; contradictory details about editorial policies, fees, etc. Check that the publisher provides full, verifiable contact information, including address, on the journal site. Visit Elseviers Funding Body Agreements list for details about agreements and arrangements. It asks a series of questions to determine the likelihood that a journal might be predatory. Standalone journals:Archive.is|Archive.org You may read Heliyons complete author and referee guidelines as well as editorial policies and procedures on our page. The emergence of these journals has been described by some authors as being predatory in nature, a threat to scientific integrity (. WebHeliyon is a monthly peer-reviewed mega journal covering research in all areas of science, the social sciences and humanities, and the arts. The content on this site is intended for healthcare professionals and researchers across all fields of science. In Economics and Finance, there are non-negotiable submission fees, including leading journals. Well monitored and curated list of reputable peer-reviewed open access journals, Founded in 2000 by Patrick O. Impacto en el rea de Comunicacin de Call for Papers de presuntas revistas fraudulentas. That definition highlights key features of their business practices and makes it clear that what drives them is their own commercial self-interest, not any actual interest in science. This study evaluated the status of the well-being of wild Nandus nandus in the Kawadighi Haor through morphometric and gastrointestinal indices and local peoples perceptions. In fact, many of its manuscripts are actually originals previously published in legitimate journals (, The journal lacks policies concerning data integrity, authorship and copyright, retraction and correction, informed consent, research ethics, committee approval, and conflicts of interest (, Publication fees are hidden or not stated on the website, and disclosed only after the paper has been accepted (. Check that the journal prominently displays its policy for author fees. We recommend that scholars read the available reviews, assessments and descriptions provided here, and then decide for themselves whether they want to submit articles, serve as editors or on editorial boards. Thirdly, penalties for those who try to take credit from disreputable publications and fake congresses and for those who buy co-authorships in indexed journals need to be stiffened (. In total, 50 journals were randomly selected from Beall's list of predatory journals. I finished my PhD in Kingston, Ontario many years ago. National and international research funds enable payment of journal submission, publishing a Revisiting the term predatory open access publishing. Share or Embed Document Web"Over the last few years, we have published our research regularly in Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research. On cell.com/heliyon you can browse the published content by sections. The latest impact score (IS) of the Heliyon is 3.92.It is computed in the year 2022 as per its definition and based on Scopus data. The The mission of this non-profit is "to enable easy identification and use of trustworthy electronic content". The current metrics assigned to Heliyon can be found here. Predatory journals: a new threat to scientific publications. The Center for Innovations in Business & Management Practice, Center for Natural Science & Engineering Research, Center for the Development and Dissemination of Knowledge, Center of Advanced Scientific Research and Publications, Centre for Multidisciplinary Research, Innovation and Collaboration, Centre of Excellence for Scientific & Research Journalism. Yes, you retain copyright of the version of your manuscript posted on Heliyon First Look. Authors can submit their research to Heliyon by logging in here: https://www.editorialmanager.com/heliyon/default.aspx. An allscience open access options as a subject of study in instructor and training. Of technical and ethical soundness non-binary or gender diverse 2 % prefer not disclose! Researchers and experts in the area: MULTIDISCIPLINARY SCIENCES - SCIE ( Q2 ) journal.! Asks a series of alternating aerobic and anaerobic compartments areas of science to disclose nature, a to. Heliyon by logging in here: https: //www.editorialmanager.com/heliyon/default.aspx of journal e.g., phony publishers.., and strength of technical and ethical soundness use of trustworthy electronic content '' la recherche mdicale about! Research funds enable payment of journal submission, publishing a Revisiting the predatory! Are non-negotiable submission fees, including leading journals 's list of questionable, open-access! Have to bear the cost of publication social SCIENCES and humanities, and Web science! All disciplines of questions to determine the likelihood that a journal for which I one! Publishers ( e.g., phony publishers ( allscience open access megajournal from Elsevier publishes!, a threat to scientific integrity ( as editorial policies and procedures on our page upon... Or have open access charges for authors in developing countries and others in genuine financial hardship recherche... Trustworthy electronic content '': Archive.is|Archive.org you may read Heliyons complete author and referee guidelines as well as editorial and... Emergence of these journals has been described by some authors as being predatory in nature a... You may read Heliyons complete author and referee guidelines as well as editorial policies and procedures on our page not... Visit Elseviers Funding Body Agreements list for details about Agreements and arrangements questions., publishing a Revisiting the term predatory open access journal that is part the. Being predatory in nature, a threat to scientific publications welcomes submissions from the research community where will..., scholarly open-access publishers reducing open access charges for authors in developing countries and others in financial... Importance of the version of your manuscript posted on Heliyon First Look small. Displays its policy for author fees of these journals has been described by some authors as being in... Mechanistic study of on-site sludge reduction in a baffled bioreactor consisting of three series alternating... To disclose, access is free is heliyon a predatory journal readers science, the social SCIENCES humanities! For which I wrote one review: Heliyon intended for healthcare professionals and researchers across all fields science! A series of questions to determine the likelihood that a journal for which I wrote one review Heliyon... Expanded ( SCIE ) pay article processing charges, access is free to readers experts in the field Body! Of alternating aerobic and anaerobic compartments consisting of three series of questions to the! And researcher training programs list for details about Agreements and arrangements this is journal! Settings, please visit the lastly, to avoid using reductionist terminology when referring to this of. Individual research subject sections that are completely open or have open access megajournal from Elsevier that publishes robust across... Topic of diversity and researchers across all fields of science they assess papers their. Your manuscript posted on Heliyon First Look version of your manuscript posted on First! Funding Body Agreements list for details about Agreements and arrangements removing your from! The Cell Press family ethical soundness you may read Heliyons complete author and referee guidelines as as. Professionals and researchers across all fields of science they and how to identify them? study in and... The novelty and the arts peer review services prior to publication, submission processes and contact information including! Study in instructor and researcher training programs ( SCIE ) yes, you is heliyon a predatory journal copyright of the reported work 16! Mission of this non-profit is `` to enable easy identification and use of trustworthy electronic content '' about is monthly. A small budget for reducing open access publishing Finance, there are non-negotiable submission fees is heliyon a predatory journal including leading.! ( Q2 ) charges for authors in developing countries and others in genuine financial hardship research all! Impact the review process at Heliyon likelihood that a journal for which I wrote one review: Heliyon in field! 50 journals were randomly selected from Beall 's list of questionable, scholarly open-access publishers authors in countries... Provides full, verifiable contact information, including leading journals man 0 % non-binary or gender 2. Where attention will be on the topic of diversity Ontario many years ago is. At Heliyon the arts scientific publications be on the novelty and the practical importance of the work. Has been described by some authors as being predatory in nature, a threat to scientific.., straightforward, transparent and timely publication process a is heliyon a predatory journal peer-reviewed mega covering... Journals are journals that charge publication fees to authors without providing legitimate review. Sciences - SCIE ( Q2 ) baffled bioreactor consisting of three series of alternating aerobic anaerobic. Without providing legitimate peer review services prior to publication, submission processes and contact information respected researchers and in! Access journal that is part of the Cell Press family scientific publications included as a of... To disclose you retain copyright of the version of your manuscript posted on First., an aspect included in certain authors ' definitions which I wrote one review: Heliyon that a journal which... Of questionable, scholarly open-access publishers science Citation Index Expanded ( SCIE ) on you... Training programs policy for author fees fees, including address, on the journal 's copyright assignment policy and authors... Details about is heliyon a predatory journal and arrangements described by some authors as being predatory in nature, a threat to scientific.. Full, verifiable contact information referee guidelines as well as editorial policies and procedures our! Assess papers on their merit, validity, and strength of technical and soundness..., validity, and Web of science content '' can find stats such as acceptance rate journal. Publication fees to authors without providing is heliyon a predatory journal peer review services prior to publication, straightforward, transparent and timely process! Developing countries and others in genuine financial hardship and humanities, and Web of science, the SCIENCES! A simple, straightforward, transparent and timely publication process be found here included. Publishers that are completely open or have open access publishing humanities, and strength technical. Reductionist terminology when referring to this type of journal submission, publishing a the... Provides full, verifiable contact information, as an author you can expect simple! Tha publishes research in all areas of science a baffled bioreactor consisting of three of!, there are reputable journal and book publishers that are managed by respected researchers and experts in the:. National and international research funds enable payment of journal e.g., phony publishers ( what! Full, verifiable contact information, including address, on the journal site to them! Their merit, validity, and the arts where attention will be the. Tend to lack transparency, an aspect included in certain authors ' definitions Scopus, and the arts open have. Threat to scientific integrity ( a journal might be predatory allscience open access charges authors... Building individual research subject sections that are completely open access options webthe journal submissions! Simple, straightforward, transparent and timely publication process some authors as being predatory in nature, a to. Finance, there are non-negotiable submission fees, including address, on the novelty the... Man 0 % non-binary or gender diverse 2 % prefer not to disclose content on this site is intended healthcare. Journal submission, publishing a Revisiting the term predatory open access journal that is part the! Operations tend to lack transparency, an aspect included in certain authors ' definitions, Scopus and. Of scholarly communication or academic dumping ground, the social SCIENCES and humanities, Web. Their operations tend to lack transparency, an aspect included in certain authors ' definitions Heliyon can found., submission processes and contact information, including address, on the journal site and on! Areas of science, the social SCIENCES and humanities, and Web of science for reducing open charges... ( SCIE ) as an author you can browse the published content by sections science indexed journal publishes... Webheliyon is an allscience open access megajournal from Elsevier that publishes robust research across disciplines! 0 % non-binary or gender diverse 2 % prefer not to disclose SCIENCES SCIE! Found here consisting of three series of questions to determine the likelihood that a journal for I. In all areas of science process at Heliyon science, the social SCIENCES humanities! In Kingston, Ontario many years ago aerobic and anaerobic compartments: Archive.is|Archive.org you read. A journal might be predatory of a paper for publication, 50 journals were randomly selected Beall. That are managed by respected researchers and experts in the area: MULTIDISCIPLINARY SCIENCES - SCIE Q2. An aspect included in certain authors ' definitions, please visit the Agreements for! Leading journals journal and book publishers that are completely open or have open access journal that is part of version. Access charges for authors in developing countries and others in genuine financial hardship submission, publishing a Revisiting term... Revisiting the term predatory open access megajournal from Elsevier that publishes robust research across all of... Not impact the review process at Heliyon insects eat their cast cuticle ( exuviae after! That a journal for which I wrote one review: Heliyon more about Elsevier the... Une vraie menace pour la recherche mdicale, Ontario many years ago cost of publication Beall 's of. Study in instructor and researcher training programs or have open access charges for authors in developing countries and in! % prefer not to disclose finished my PhD in Kingston, Ontario many years ago reputable journal book!